Frequently Asked Questions
A “Class Action” is a lawsuit that is filed on behalf
of all individuals or entities that may have been similarly affected by the
allegations brought before the Court. In a class action, if the Court approves
a settlement, the Settlement Class Members share in any benefits provided by
the Settlement and are bound by the terms of the Settlement Agreement.
CSST is used to transmit gas in residential, commercial
and industrial structures. CSST consists of a continuous, flexible, stainless
steel pipe, and typically is covered with a yellow exterior plastic coating. In
the case of one of the products manufactured by OmegaFlex, called
“COUNTERSTRIKE,” the product is covered with a black exterior coating with
yellow lettering. CSST typically is routed beneath, through and alongside floor
joists, inside interior wall cavities and on top of ceiling joists in attic
space from a gas source to an appliance. CSST does not include gas-appliance
connectors (e.g., a connector that runs from a gas outlet to an
appliance). Titeflex's CSST product is known as “GASTITE,” Ward's CSST product
is known as “WARDFLEX,” OmegaFlex’s CSST is known as “TRACPIPE” or
“COUNTERSTRIKE,” and Parker Hannifin’s CSST product is known as “PARFLEX.”
The lawsuit claims that CSST poses an unreasonable risk
of fire due to lightning strikes. Plaintiffs allege that the CSST tubing is not
thick enough to prevent damage to the CSST in the event of a lightning strike
and that Defendants failed to warn consumers about these alleged dangers.
The Settling Defendants deny these allegations and assert that their CSST is
safe if properly installed in accordance with local codes and the
manufacturers’ instructions.
Typically, these products may be visible along floor
joists, above basements, in attic spaces, or connected to exposed appliances
such as water heaters. The piping should be stamped with a manufacturer’s mark.
Click
here
to see examples of the Settling Defendants’ products.
Yes. The CSST installed on your property may have been
manufactured by Titeflex, Ward, OmegaFlex, or Parker Hannifin.
Titeflex's CSST is stamped with the mark “GASTITE.”
Ward's CSST is stamped with the mark “WARDFLEX.”
OmegaFlex's CSST is stamped with the marks “TRACPIPE” or “COUNTERSTRIKE.”
Parker Hannifin's CSST is stamped with the mark “PARFLEX.”
The Settlement Class consists of any and all persons
and/or entities who own structures in the United States in which CSST
manufactured by Settling Defendants was installed as of September 5, 2006
(“Settlement Class Members”).
The following persons are excluded from the Settlement Class: a) persons and/or
entities who timely opt-out of this proceeding following the directions for
opting-out established by the Court; b) any and all federal, state, and/or
local governments, including, but not limited to, their departments, agencies,
divisions, bureaus, boards, sections, groups, counsels and/or subdivisions; c)
any currently sitting Arkansas state court judges and/or justices and/or any
persons within the third degree of consanguinity (blood relationship) to such
judges and/or justices; d) Settling Defendants; e) Plaintiffs’ Counsel and
their immediate families; and f) any person or entity who as of September 5,
2006, has an individual personal injury, product liability or subrogation
lawsuit pending against any of the Settling Defendants in which injury or
damage is alleged to have occurred as a result of a failure of CSST resulting
from an actual or near lightning strike.
The Proposed Settlement provides Payment Vouchers for
Settlement Class Members who qualify for relief. These Vouchers defray the
costs of buying and installing a lightning protection system or completing the
bonding and grounding of certain systems in a structure.
Settlement Class Members who have CSST manufactured by Settling Defendants will
be entitled to a Payment Voucher that can be used either toward the
installation of a Lightning Protection System or for the completion of Bonding
and Grounding. Payment Voucher values range from $200 to $2,000 for the
installation of a Lightning Protection System to $75 to $160 for the completion
of Bonding and Grounding. To determine what Lightning Density Zone the property
is located in, visit the
Find Your Lightning Density Zone
page.
Section L of the
Settlement
Agreement requires the Defendants to make certain marketing changes.
You may review details of these marketing changes
here.
Class Counsel (Counsel for the Plaintiffs) are:
W. H. “Dub” Arnold
Attorney at Law
501 Crittenden
Arkadelphia, AR 71923
John Goodson
Matt Keil
Keil & Goodson P.A.
611 Pecan Street
Texarkana, AR 71854-5337
|
Cary Patterson
Michael Angelovich
Nix, Patterson & Roach
2900 St. Michael, Fifth Floor
Texarkana, TX 75503
Joel Fineberg
R. Dean Gresham
Law Offices of Joel M. Fineberg P.C.
3811 Turtle Creek Blvd. Suite 1900
Dallas, TX 75219
|
You are automatically a Settlement Class Member if you
own a structure with CSST manufactured by Settling Defendants that was
installed as of September 5, 2006 and are not among the categories of persons
excluded from participation.
Your options as a Settlement Class Member:
-
To stay in the Settlement Class, Settlement Class Members do not have to do
anything. Settlement Class Members who follow the claims procedures are
eligible to receive the benefits of the Settlement; all Settlement Class
Members who stay in the Settlement Class will be bound by the Court’s rulings
and opinions in this Settlement and will have released certain claims against
the Settling Defendants.
-
Settlement Class Members can write and ask to exclude themselves from the
Settlement. If a Settlement Class Member excludes himself, he will not be able
to file a claim, will not receive benefits from the Settlement, but will keep
the right to sue the Defendants on his own about the claims in the Settlement
Class.
-
If a Settlement Class Member does not exclude himself from the Settlement, he
can appear and speak at the Fairness Hearing on his own or through his own
lawyer by following certain procedures.
If you exclude yourself from the Settlement, you will
receive none of the Settlement benefits, nor will you be bound by any terms
approved by the Court.
The Request for Exclusion must be postmarked on or before January 8, 2007.
If you do not want to receive the benefits of the Settlement but want to keep
the right to individually sue the Settling Defendants concerning the claims
released in this case, then you must take steps to remove yourself from the
Class. This is called excluding yourself from, or opting out of the Settlement
Class. To be excluded from this lawsuit, you must personally sign and return
the
Request for Exclusion Form
to the address listed on the Form.
The Request for Exclusion must be postmarked on or before January 8, 2007.
You may
not exclude yourself by leaving a phone
message.
CSST Settlement Administrator
PO Box4349
Portland, OR 97208-4349
A Fairness Hearing will be held on February 1, 2007
before the Honorable John A. Thomas, 401 Clay, Arkadelphia, AR 71923. The
Fairness Hearing will determine whether the Proposed Settlement is fair,
reasonable and adequate. The Hearing may be continued by the Court without
further written notice.
At the Fairness Hearing, Settlement Class Members who did not exclude
themselves may appear in person or by counsel (at his or her own expense) and
be heard to the extent allowed by the Court in support of, or in opposition to,
the fairness, reasonableness and adequacy of the Proposed Settlement Agreement.
On or before January 8, 2007, Settlement Class Members
must file a notice of intent to appear at the February 1, 2007 Fairness
Hearing.
Settlement Class Members must include in that filing a statement of all factual
and legal grounds upon which the objection is based, together with sufficient
proof that CSST exists in their property and that identifies the CSST
manufacturer.
Sufficient proof may include: (a) a receipt or invoice that identifies the
property and CSST manufacturer; and (b) a photograph of the manufacturer’s
identifying mark on the CSST, together with a signed statement that the
photograph was taken from the Objector’s Structure. Should you or your lawyer
object, you must follow all Arkansas rules. If you object and the Court
approves the Settlement anyway, you will be bound by the result.
Any such objection
MUST be sent to all of the following:
Clerk for the Clark Circuit Court
401 Clay Street
Arkadelphia, AR 71923
John Goodson
KEIL & GOODSON P.A.
611 Pecan Street
Texarkana, AR 71854-5337
Scott T. Schutte
JENNER & BLOCK LLP
330 N. Wabash Ave
Chicago, IL 60611-7603
|
Robert B. Ellis
KIRKLAND & ELLIS
200 East Randolph Drive, 60th Floor
Chicago, IL 60601
J. Gordon Cooney, Jr.
MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS, L.L.P.
1701 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Robert Walker
JONES DAY
901 Lakeside Avenue
Cleveland, OH 44114-1190
|
Settlement Class Members who do not exclude themselves
from the Class automatically agree to “release” Titeflex, Ward, OmegaFlex and
Parker Hannifin from certain claims. These “Released Claims” include all
claims, demands, rights, liabilities and causes of action that were asserted or
might have been asserted by the Settlement Class Members against the Settling
Defendants, whether sounding in tort, contract, any state’s unfair competition
or consumer protection law, or any other law of any state or jurisdiction, and
whether for compensatory damages, economic damages, non-economic damages,
restitution, penalties, attorneys’ fees or any other relief, so long as the
claim, demand, right, liability, or cause of action constitutes, arises out of,
relates to, or is in connection with:
the causes of action asserted against Settling Defendants in the Action,
including, but not limited to, any and all claims that Settling Defendants are
strictly liable, breached any warranties or that they misled the public,
concealed dangers, were involved in a conspiracy, or otherwise violated any law
whatsoever by designing, manufacturing, marketing, selling CSST or placing CSST
into the stream of commerce;
any facts, transactions, events, policies, occurrences, acts, disclosures,
statements, or omissions or failures to act, which were or could have been
asserted as a basis of or in connection with any of the claims in the Action;
or
all claims asserted or that could have been asserted by Plaintiffs in the
Action that a member of the Settlement Class had or could have had against
Settling Defendants with respect to CSST installed in their Property.
These Released Claims expressly include all claims that were or could have been
brought against any person or entity in the chain of distribution of CSST
designed, manufactured, marketed or sold by Settling Defendants, including but
not limited to manufacturers, component suppliers, distributors, wholesalers,
retailers, sales representatives, installers, general contractors or
subcontractors.
Released Claims do not include claims for damages as a result of an actual gas
leak, including but not limited to claims for damages from fire, loss of
property or the use of property or personal injury, nor is any release given by
Settlement Class Members for such compensatory damage claims, nor would any bar
exist for such compensatory damage claims by entry of a judgment of dismissal
in the Action. In the event that a Settlement Class Member brings such a
subsequent action against one or more Settling Defendant, any Settling
Defendant may assert in response to those claims any and all defenses,
including but not limited to comparative fault, contributory negligence,
assumption of risk, exercise of reasonable care, laches or failure to mitigate
damages. The viability of any defenses will be determined by the law that
governs each such subsequent action, if any, brought against any Settling
Defendant. The Settlement shall not be construed as a waiver of, or a
determination of, the existence or availability of any defense.
Additional information regarding these released claims may be found on pages 5
and 6 of the Notice of Proposed Class Action Settlement.
No. You will not have to appear in Court, nor will you
have to give any testimony other than the facts you submit on your Claim Form.
Settlement Class Members who wish to make a claim must
submit a Claim Form by
September 5, 2007. The Claim Form,
attached to the notice and available to be completed online, requests certain
information, including the following:
-
The address and county of the property, as well as a clear photograph of the
main structure;
-
Photographic or otherwise sufficient proof that the CSST installed on your
property was manufactured by one of the Settling Defendants;
-
The estimated square footage of the interior heated/air-conditioned portion of
the property incorporating CSST;
-
A sworn verification that the Settling Class Member owns the property or
otherwise has authority to install a Lightning Protection System or Bonding and
Grounding; and
-
A sworn verification that CSST was installed before September 5, 2006.
A Settlement Class Member who submits a proper Claim Form on time will be sent
the following information and materials: one numbered Payment Voucher for a
Lightning Protection system and one voucher for Bonding and Grounding. Vouchers
will be pre-printed with the Settlement Class Member’s name, property address,
and Payment Voucher amounts. The claimants will also receive additional
information regarding how to use the Payment Voucher. Please note that payment
vouchers cannot be sent until after the Settlement becomes final. Please
check the website or toll-free number periodically for updates regarding the
status of the Settlement.
The amount, if any, to be paid under the Payment Voucher is subject to
verification of, the presence of a Settling Defendant’s product, the square
footage of the structure (in the case of a Lightning Protection System), proof
of a Lightning Protection System installation and/or Bonding and Grounding
pursuant to the terms of the Proposed Settlement, and proof of the cost of
installation, all following installation of a Lightning Protection System or
Bonding and Grounding. This information will be determined and reported by the
Third-Party Vendor.
If you do not submit a timely Claim Form, you will not
receive any of the Settlement benefits. Further, if you do not submit a Request
for Exclusion, you will be bound by the terms of the Settlement even if you do
not submit a claim.
Yes. The Court has approved the Settlement. The
Effective Date of the Settlement is March 5, 2007.
Class Counsel believe, in light of the substantial
benefits of the Proposed Settlement, balanced against the costs, risks and
delay of continued litigation, the Proposed Settlement is in the best interests
of the Class and is a fair, reasonable and adequate resolution of the lawsuit
and of the issues it presents.
In addition to all other sums to be paid by Settling
Defendants under the terms of the Proposed Settlement, Settling Defendants will
pay to Class Counsel reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs. Class Counsel will
request a fee of no more than $29,200,000. Settling Defendants have agreed not
to object to a fee request up to that amount. No attorneys' fees will
be deducted from the benefits paid to Settlement Class Members. Class
Counsels’ request for fees will be considered by the Court at the Fairness
Hearing scheduled for February 1, 2007.
The amount of the voucher, per claim, will be
determined by criteria that are described in the “Payment Voucher Schedule,”
that takes into account the remedy that you choose, the square footage of your
property, as well as established data regarding the number of lightning flashes
per square kilometer, each year, in your particular zone.
For Zone 1, an area with more than 8.0 flashes per square kilometer per year,
the Settlement would provide a voucher of $1,000 towards the purchase and
installation of a Lightning Protection System on property of less than 3,000
sq. ft. For property more than 3,000 sq. ft., the voucher would be $2,000. For
those who choose the Bonding and Grounding Option, the voucher would be $160
towards the completion of the Bonding and Grounding.
For Zone 2, an area with 4.0 to 8.0 flashes per square kilometer per year; the
Settlement would provide a voucher of $600 towards the purchase and
installation of a Lightening Protection System on property of less than 3,000
sq. ft. For property more than 3,000 sq. ft., the voucher would be $1,200. For
those who choose the Bonding and Grounding Option, the voucher would be $100
towards the completion of the Bonding and Grounding.
For Zone 3, an area with less than 4.0 flashes per square kilometer per year,
the Settlement would provide a voucher of $200 towards the purchase and
installation of a Lightening Protection System on property of less than 3,000
sq. ft. For property more than 3,000 sq. ft., the voucher would be $400. For
those who choose the Bonding and Grounding Option, the voucher would be $75
towards the completion of the Bonding and Grounding.
To determine what Lightning Density Zone the property is located in, visit the
Find Your Lightning Density Zone page.
The Claim Form provides that you submit a photograph
or otherwise sufficient proof that CSST installed by one of the Settling
Defendants is installed on the property. The TPV responsible for the
installation of the LPS or Bonding and Grounding will confirm that you have an
eligible product and submit proof in connection with the claim verification
process.
The Lightning Protection System will provide a measure
of protection against lightning for your entire structure and many of its
systems, including electrical, telephone, plumbing and gas-delivery systems.
The Settling Defendants do not believe that a Lightning Protection System is
necessary to render their CSST safe. They do agree, however, that such a system
reduces the risks to the entire structure and many of its systems, including
CSST.
Bonding and Grounding also reduces the risk of damage from a lightning strike.
Bonding and Grounding consists of tying together certain systems in a structure
that are likely to be energized by a lightning strike to reduce the differences
in the so-called “potential” among those systems. This reduces the likelihood
of potentially destructive electrical arcing among such systems. For many
years, Settling Defendants’ Design and Installation Guides instructed that CSST
must be Bonded and Grounded in accordance with applicable codes.
The Proposed Settlement Agreement provides the means
for a Settlement Class Member to defray the cost of purchasing a Lightning
Protection System or Bonding and Grounding.
Settlement Class Members may use Payment Vouchers to defray the cost of having
the Third-Party Vendor install a Lightning Protection System or complete the
Bonding and Grounding of certain systems in the structure. This Third-Party
Vendor is not affiliated with the Settling Parties and was selected by
Plaintiffs’ Counsel after a nationwide search. In addition, no party has a
financial incentive for Settlement Class Members to use the Third-Party Vendor.
The amount of the Payment Voucher will vary depending on the lightning density
(in flashes/square kilometer/year) in the county in which the structure is
located and, in the case of a Lightning Protection System, the size of the
structure.
The amount of the Payment Voucher is based on data regarding the relative risk
of a lightning strike in the county in which the structure is located, as well
as the size of the structure in which CSST was installed, as set forth in the
Payment Voucher Schedule.
The Payment Voucher will be applied to the cost of the LPS or B&G. Costs of
B&G can vary greatly depending on your structure and location and will be
determined by the TPV as part of the Claims process. LPS costs can also vary,
but the estimated cost of LPS can be found on the Pricing Matrix on the
Claim Submission page. A Good Faith Estimate from the TPV will be
provided as part of the Claims process.
To determine what zone the property is located in, visit the
Find Your Lightning Density Zone page.
To have the property inspected each Settlement Class
Member must complete the
Claim Form. Once the
Settlement Class Member submits the claim, the Administrator will verify the
Claim Form and then arrange for the Third-Party Vendor to inspect the home or
building to confirm:
-
That the home or structure contains the Settling Defendants’ CSST;
-
That the CSST is Bonded and Grounded; and
-
The approximate square-footage of the heated/air-conditioned structure.
There is no charge to you for the inspection.
Additional information on the Settlement, including a
copy of the Settlement Agreement may be found on the
Court
Documents page. You may also contact the CSST Settlement Administrator
through the following methods.
Call:
1-800-420-2916
Write:
CSST Settlement Administrator
P.O. Box 4349
Portland, OR 97208-4349
Renters may not participate in the Settlement, but may
contact the owner of their property who may participate in the Settlement.
The Settlement provides that each separate structure
that contains CSST at a single mailing address may receive a separate payment
voucher. If each unit in a development is a separate structure, it is eligible
to receive a separate voucher. If there are multiple units in one structure,
only one voucher may be issued. In multi-unit situations, please refer to the
governing documentation for your structure to determine who has the legal
authority to determine whether or not to participate in the Settlement. The
Settlement identifies the Settlement Class Member as the person who has the
legal authority to enter into a contract for the installation of a Lighting
Protection System and Bonding and Grounding. For example, in a condominium, the
governing documentation for that condominium might specify that the condominium
Association has the authority to enter into such agreement. In that case, the
Association would be the Settlement Class Member.
The Settlement provides that each separate structure
that contains CSST at a single mailing address may receive a separate payment
voucher. If each unit in a development is a separate structure, it is eligible
to receive a separate voucher. If there are multiple units in one structure,
only one voucher may be issued. In multi-unit situations, please refer to the
governing documentation for your structure to determine who has the legal
authority to determine whether or not to participate in the Settlement. The
Settlement identifies the Settlement Class Member as the person who has the
legal authority to enter into a contract for the installation of a Lighting
Protection System and Bonding and Grounding. For example, in a condominium, the
governing documentation for that condominium might specify that the condominium
Association has the authority to enter into such agreement. In that case, the
Association would be the Settlement Class Member.
Because lightning is one of the most destructive
forces on earth, there can be no guarantee that any measure can be taken to
completely eliminate the risk of lightning. Installation of a lightning
protection system (“LPS”) will decrease the risk of damage from a direct
lightning strike, and proper bonding and grounding (which is included if a
Settlement Class Member chooses to install an LPS) will decrease the risk of
damage from a near (or indirect) lightning strike.
No.
No.
Vouchers must be used within 24 months of the
Effective Date. We will update the toll-free number and the website to include
this information once we know the date the Settlement approval becomes final.
Yes.
That is a question we are unable to answer; you should
consult your insurance agent for any insurance related questions.
The Settlement does not cover these costs.
The Third-Party Vendor is Bonded Lightning Protection
Systems, LTD. If you submit a Claim Form, we will provide you with
information concerning how to arrange for an inspection and the price quote for
your property. More information about Bonded Lightning Protection Systems, LTD
may be obtained from their website:
www.bondedlp.com.
Certain disputes, such as any and all disputes
concerning the eligibility of a property for a payment voucher, are to be
submitted to the Neutral Evaluator, who is ADR, Inc. in Little Rock, Arkansas.
All other disputes are under the exclusive jurisdiction of the District Court
of Clark County, Arkansas. For more information, consult the Settlement
Agreement posted on the website.
The Court has approved a plan of notice, which
includes publication in major publications, including newspaper supplements,
national consumer magazines and trade publications.
Costs associated with Bonding and Grounding (B&G)
can vary greatly depending on your structure and location. Costs for B&G
will be determined by the TPV as part of the Claims process. Lightning
Protection System (LPS) costs can also vary, but the estimated cost of LPS can
be found on the Pricing Matrix on the
Claim Submission
page. A Good Faith Estimate from the TPV will be provided as part of the Claims
process.
Yes. You will receive a letter detailing what about
your claim was incomplete and given a period of time to remedy the issue(s).
If your home or structure has already been Bonded and Grounded, but
you do not have a Lightning Protection System installed, you may still be entitled to
benefits from the Settlement. To receive benefits, you must file a claim. If your
claim is valid, you would be eligible to receive a Payment Voucher that can be used
toward the installation of a Lightning Protection System through the Settlement.
Claimants who had a LPS installed prior to September 5, 2006 may
be eligible for a special monetary benefit by submitting a Previously Installed LPS Claim Form.
The form must be requested from the Settlement Administrator by calling 1 (800) 420-2916. The
deadline to submit these claims is September 5, 2007.
If you intend to redeem the voucher you received as part of the CSST Settlement, you must submit a completed Questionnaire to the Settlement Administrator postmarked no later than March 5, 2008. All Lightning Protection System and Bonding and Grounding work as part of a voucher redemption must be completed on or before March 5, 2009.